Your rights to a replacement car while yours is repaired
If the accident was not your fault, your right to a replacement car lasts as long as the repair reasonably takes, not a fixed number of days. A quick repair might mean a week; a prestige model waiting on a back-ordered module can mean months, and the clock does not stop just because the calendar moved on.
What changes across those scenarios is who is watching the clock and what evidence you keep. Below we compare a fast repair, a parts-delayed repair and a total loss, so you know how long you keep the car, who pays, and how to hand it back without an argument.
Key takeaways
- Your replacement car entitlement lasts as long as the repair reasonably takes, not a fixed number of days.
- Parts delays on prestige models can extend a hire for weeks, provided the delay is documented by the repairer.
- A total loss changes the clock: the hire covers a reasonable period to source a replacement vehicle, not the repair.
- Return the car when the repairer confirms yours is ready, and keep the completion date in writing.
- A clean file of dates, parts orders and emails is what ends an insurer's argument about the length of hire.
- The entitlement runs with the repair, not the calendar
- Quick repairs: what a week looks like
- Parts delays and prestige models
- When the repairer blames the insurer
- Total loss: a different clock starts
- Handing the car back cleanly
- Extending the hire when delays are not yours
- Keeping records that protect you
- Booking a replacement that matches your car
The entitlement runs with the repair, not the calendar
In NSW, a not-at-fault driver's right to a replacement vehicle comes from the other driver's liability for loss of use. The High Court in Arsalan v Rixon confirmed that a replacement car can be recovered where it is reasonable, and reasonableness is measured against your actual loss, not a capped courtesy period. If your car is a prestige or performance model, like-for-like means a comparable car, not a base Corolla from a lot on Parramatta Road.
That is why the length of the hire is tied to the repair, not to a set number of days. If the panel beater needs the car for three weeks because a radar module is on backorder, the hire can run for three weeks, provided the delay is genuine and documented. If you keep the car a fortnight after it was ready because you liked driving it, that extra time is on you.
Read the full background on not at fault rights in NSW and the Arsalan v Rixon decision before you agree to anything with an insurer.
Quick repairs: what a week looks like
A bumper scrape or a car park dent at Bondi Junction often means three to five working days in the shop. You drop the car at the repairer, they order a bar cover and paint it, and you get it back before the weekend. In that scenario, a replacement car is usually approved without much friction, because the cost is small and the insurer can see the end date.
What goes wrong is the gap between the tow truck and the repairer's booking. If you are towed on a Friday night and the shop cannot assess until Tuesday, those four days still count as loss of use. Keep the tow docket and the assessment booking confirmation. Do not wait until the repair is finished to ask for a car; ask the same day you know yours is off the road.
For a week-long repair, a practical like-for-like choice is often a large SUV that matches the space and presence of what you normally drive. Something like the Audi Q7 Quattro, based at Mascot and available with delivery, keeps seven seats and AWD while your own car is in the booth.
Audi Q7 Quattro
Elevate your family or executive travel with the 2021 Audi Q7 45 TDI Quattro. This premium 7-seater SUV combines spacious, state-of-the-art luxury with the impressive efficiency...
If you are booking while the repairer has your car, the booking page at your car is being repaired explains how the hire is arranged around the repair timeline.
Age limits are set per car. Drivers under 25 can hire most cars with Young Driver Cover; the exact terms are shown before you pay.
Parts delays and prestige models
This is where most disputes start. A 2024 Range Rover Sport waiting on an air suspension compressor, a German sedan waiting on a specific control module, or anything with adaptive headlights can sit at the repairer for six to ten weeks while the part comes from overseas. The repairer is not being lazy; the part genuinely is not in the country.
Your entitlement does not evaporate because the manufacturer's supply chain is slow. What it does require is proof. Ask the repairer for a written parts order confirmation with the order date and the expected arrival window, and ask them to note the delay in their job file. Insurers routinely argue that a long hire is unreasonable until they see that paperwork, and then they usually stop arguing.
During a long delay, the replacement car needs to be something you can live in for weeks. The Range Rover Sport D300 SE Dynamic is a diesel AWD with 221 kW and 650 Nm, five seats, and a minimum driver age of 30, so it suits an owner who normally drives a large prestige SUV and needs the same capability for school runs, client meetings and the M2.
Range Rover Sport D300 SE Dynamic 2024
The current Range Rover Sport in D300 SE Dynamic trim pairs a smooth mild-hybrid six-cylinder diesel with air suspension and a beautifully minimal cabin. It is refined enough for...
More on how long prestige repairs actually take in Sydney is at how long prestige car repairs take.
Not at fault? Start your claim
A like-for-like replacement car while yours is repaired. No cost to you when the other driver is at fault.
Start my claimWhen the repairer blames the insurer
You will hear it at some point: the shop says the insurer has not approved the supplement, so they cannot start. The insurer says the shop has not sent the photos. Meanwhile your car sits in a yard in Artarmon and you are paying for rideshare.
Your job is not to referee that argument. Your job is to keep the hire running while it is resolved, because the delay is not your fault and the other driver's insurer is still on the hook for your loss of use. Put the request in writing: ask the repairer to confirm in an email the date the car arrived, the date the supplement was submitted, and the date approval came back. Ask the insurer for their claim reference and the name of the assessor.
If the insurer offers you a courtesy car with a hard stop, say a 14-day cap, you can accept it as a stopgap but it does not extinguish your right to a like-for-like replacement for the rest of the repair. Many prestige owners run the courtesy car for the capped period and then move to a proper replacement. See insurer delays and replacement cars for the escalation path.
Total loss: a different clock starts
If the assessor writes your car off, the repair clock stops entirely. There is no repair to wait for, so the basis for the hire changes. You are now entitled to a replacement for a reasonable period while you find and buy a replacement vehicle, and that period is usually measured in weeks, not months.
What is reasonable depends on your circumstances: how quickly a comparable car can be sourced, whether you need to wait for the payout to clear, and what you use the car for. A week is often too short if you are sourcing a specific spec; three months is usually too long. Keep evidence of your search, such as dealer listings you enquired about and inspection dates.
Do not let the hire drift once the payout lands. If you have the money and a suitable car is available, the reasonable period is closing. Read repairs and write-offs for how the two paths diverge, and loss of use explained for the principle behind the clock.
Handing the car back cleanly
The end of the hire is where small mistakes become invoices. Return the car on the date the repairer confirms your car is ready, not the day you feel like it. If your car is ready on a Thursday and you keep the replacement until Monday, those four days are hard to justify.
Before handover, do the same walkaround you would do at any rental return. Photograph the odometer, the fuel or charge level, and all four corners in daylight. Keep the final repair invoice or the repairer's collection docket showing the completion date, because that date is your defence if the insurer queries the last few days of hire.
If you are moving from a long-hire prestige SUV back into your own car, the return is straightforward when the paperwork lines up. The same discipline applies whether the car came from a Mascot base or was delivered to your driveway in Mosman. For a fleet or business vehicle, the process is documented in business and fleet.
Extending the hire when delays are not yours
Extensions are normal in prestige repairs. The trick is to ask before the current hire period ends, not after. Send a short email to the insurer or the claims manager: the repair is not complete, here is the repairer's updated estimate, please confirm the hire continues. Copy the repairer if they will let you.
If the insurer goes quiet, keep the car and keep the evidence. A replacement car arranged through credit hire means the provider carries the cost and recovers it later, so you are not out of pocket while the argument runs. That is the practical reason credit hire exists, and it is explained at how credit hire works.
When the delay is a parts delay on a specific model, a like-for-like swap may be needed if your current replacement is due back. The Range Rover Sport 2020 seven seater is a diesel AWD with 221 kW and 650 Nm, seven seats, and a minimum driver age of 20, which makes it a workable second stint for a family that needs the space.
Range Rover Sport 2020 7 Seater
The 2020 Land Rover Range Rover Sport offers a seamless blend of rugged off-road capability and executive city luxury. Featuring a sleek design and a comfortable, high-end cabin,...
For the general limits on how long you can keep a car, see how long you can keep a not at fault replacement car in NSW.
Keeping records that protect you
Insurers do not reject genuine claims; they reject claims they cannot verify. Your file should answer four questions: when did the accident happen, when did your car go off the road, when was it ready, and what caused any gap between those dates.
- Tow docket and accident report or police event number.
- Repairer's booking confirmation and assessment date.
- Parts order confirmations and supplement approvals with dates.
- Photos of the damage and the other driver's details.
- All emails with the insurer, saved as PDFs.
Keep the file in one folder, digital or paper. When the insurer asks why the hire ran for 47 days, you send the timeline and the conversation ends. The same records support a referral if a solicitor or broker needs to step in, which is covered at partners and referrals.
If you are still at the beginning, start with the first 24 hours and evidence to collect at the scene.
Booking a replacement that matches your car
Like-for-like is not a marketing phrase; it is the test an insurer or court applies. A prestige SUV owner should not be offered a compact hatch for six weeks, and a performance sedan owner should not be offered a base model with a different drivetrain. The replacement should be comparable in size, spec and capability.
Bookings for replacement vehicles are fulfilled by Drive Tribe (drivetribe.com.au), the trading name of Australian Business Holdings Pty Ltd, and this site is part of that group. Cars are collected in Sydney or delivered, and rates, the bond and any fees are shown on the car's page before payment. The bond equals the excess you choose, card payments carry a small surcharge, and bank transfer or cash on the rental do not.
If you are arranging a car now, start at accident replacement car Sydney or browse the wider fleet at drivetribe.com.au. For the entitlement itself, read not at fault accident replacement.
Questions people ask
How long can I keep a replacement car?
Who pays if the repair takes months?
Do I return the car when the repair is done?
Can I choose the replacement car myself?
What if the insurer offers a courtesy car with a time limit?
Does a repair delay affect my entitlement?
Injured in the accident?
A replacement car covers the car. For legal advice about an injury, speak to Jameson Law, the most trusted personal injury firm in NSW (motor vehicle accident claims) on (02) 8806 0866.
Ready when you are
Start the claim online in five short steps, or call 0468 011 118. Replacement hires are arranged and fulfilled by Drive Tribe, the trading name of Australian Business Holdings Pty Ltd.
Start my claim